No definition of
“pension” is made in IRO. So, the Literal Rule applies so that its ordinary
meaning will be adopted. In short, pension is a periodical payment to a
person in consideration of his past services.
Section 9(3) extends the charge to cover a pension which is voluntary or is
capable of being discontinued. This provision was to overcome the decision
in Stedeford v. Beloe 16 TC 505 in which pension was held to be excluding
voluntary payments.
Like employment income, only the pension arising in or derived from Hong
Kong is assessable. This follows that we have to determine the location of
the source of the pension. From case law, the location of the fund from
which the pension is paid is the decisive factor in determining whether the
pension is arising in Hong Kong or not. But this does not mean that the
place where the assets making up the fund determines the location of the
pension. In fact, regard should be made to the place where the fund is
managed and controlled. Normally, this is situated at the place of the
business that employed the pensioner. But in some special cases, it can be
located at the place where the trustee has power to control the fund.
As far as Hong Kong government pensioners are concerned, all the pension
based on total length of service is chargeable to salaries tax, even though
part of which is attributable to services done outside Hong Kong. In all
other cases, the pension attributable to services outside Hong Kong is not
taxable.